</>EmbeddedInterview

How do you choose a wireless technology for an IoT device?

MediumCommunication Protocols

Short answer: Match range, data rate, power budget, network topology, infrastructure and cost. BLE for short range, very low power and phone connectivity; Wi-Fi for high data rates and direct internet access with mains or large batteries; Thread/Zigbee (802.15.4) for low-power mesh networks in buildings (Thread with Matter for smart homes); LoRaWAN for kilometres of range with tiny data and multi-year battery life; NB-IoT/LTE-M (cellular) for wide-area coverage without your own gateways.

BLE Wi-Fi Thread / Zigbee LoRaWAN NB-IoT / LTE-M
Range 10–100 m 30–100 m 10–100 m per hop, mesh 2–15 km km (cellular)
Data rate 1–2 Mbps PHY, ~100s kbps app 10–1000+ Mbps 250 kbps 0.3–50 kbps ~60 kbps / ~1 Mbps
Power very low high low (routers mains-powered) very low low–medium (PSM, eDRX)
Topology star (mesh possible) star (AP) mesh star of stars (gateways) star (base stations)
Infrastructure phone or gateway access point border router gateways + network server operator network, SIM
IP-native no (yes over IPv6 in some profiles) yes Thread: IPv6; Zigbee: no no yes
Typical use wearables, sensors, provisioning cameras, appliances lighting, smart home (Matter) agriculture, metering, asset tracking trackers, meters, remote equipment

Questions to ask in a design discussion

  1. How much data, how often, and with what latency?
  2. Battery or mains power, and what lifetime is required?
  3. Indoor/outdoor range, and is there existing infrastructure (Wi-Fi, phones, cellular coverage)?
  4. Cost per unit (module, certification, subscription fees for cellular).
  5. Security and provisioning (how a device joins the network securely).
  6. Regulatory regions (sub-GHz frequencies differ by region).

Common combinations: BLE for setup (phone app provisions Wi-Fi credentials) plus Wi-Fi for data; Thread devices exposed through Matter; LoRaWAN or cellular sensors with BLE for local maintenance.