</>EmbeddedInterview

What is the difference between a crystal and an RC oscillator?

EasyElectronics & Hardware Basics

Short answer: A quartz crystal (or crystal oscillator module) gives an accurate and stable frequency, typically ±10–50 ppm, needed for UART at high baud rates, USB, CAN, Ethernet, radio and real-time clocks. An internal RC oscillator costs nothing, starts quickly and saves pins and board space, but its accuracy is typically ±1–3% over temperature and voltage (factory-trimmed parts can be much better at room temperature), which is too inaccurate for USB, CAN or Ethernet and risky for fast UARTs.

Crystal (HSE, LSE) Internal RC (HSI, MSI, LSI)
Accuracy ±10–50 ppm ±0.5–3% (worse over temperature)
Start-up ms (32 kHz crystals: up to seconds) µs
Cost/pins crystal + 2 load caps, 2 pins none
Uses USB, CAN, Ethernet, radios, RTC timekeeping general CPU clock, low-power wake-up, watchdogs (LSI)

Error examples: 1% error on a clock means 14 minutes per day for an RTC, while a 20 ppm crystal drifts about 1.7 s per day. For a UART, 1% error per side is acceptable for 8N1; 3% may not be.

Board design points

  • Load capacitors: C_load = (C1 × C2)/(C1 + C2) + C_stray; for a crystal rated C_L = 12 pF with ~3 pF stray, C1 = C2 ≈ 18 pF. Wrong values shift the frequency.
  • Keep the crystal close to the MCU, with a ground guard and no signals routed underneath.
  • Check the oscillator's drive level and the MCU's recommended crystal ESR; low-power 32.768 kHz crystals are sensitive to leakage (flux residue) and layout.

Firmware: enable clock security system (CSS) to fall back to the internal oscillator if the crystal fails; trim the RC oscillator against the crystal or USB SOF (clock recovery system) where available; add timeouts when waiting for the crystal to start.